Synopsis
An up-and-coming chef and a recently divorced woman see their lives forever changed when a chance encounter brings them together, in a deeply moving romance that spans a decade
Florence Pugh described filming this project as “one of the highlights of [her] career.” Is It a SinWritten by Al HazanPlayed by Allie HazanNever has the gap between my expectations and the actual impact of the film been so great.
The script and soundtrack were totally forgettable, even though Pugh and Garfield gave great performances from what they had at their disposal
The odds were so high with the casting of two of the greatest actors of our time, and even they couldn’t make the film have soul.
Both characters fell very low and I felt very little emotional investment in them
The back-and-forth timeline made the emotional journey incomplete as there was no build-up or stakes to invest in.
Hopefully someone will cast them both in a future film and give them a better chance at creating a masterpiece
I had high hopes and was counting down the days to this film, and I was very disappointed walking out of the screening.